http://www.kentucky.com/latest_news/story/902829.html
Afraid of 'socialized' medicine? We've had it for decades
Tom Eblen - Herald-leader columnist
There's a fascinating audio clip on YouTube. It's from a 1961 phonograph record in which a politically ambitious entertainer named Ronald Reagan tries his best to scare people about "socialized medicine."
The threat he warns about is legislation to create the program we now know as Medicare.
So here we are, nearly a half-century later, with talk radio entertainers and some Republican politicians trying their best to scare people about "socialized medicine."
They see a threat in almost any meaningful reform of America's inadequate health care insurance system.
Some of their scare tactics, such as baseless claims about plans for "death panels," are truly outrageous.
- Former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin might actually believe some of the crazy things she says, but other GOP leaders who lend legitimacy to such hogwash are simply seeking political advantage.
- They seem to have no interest in improving health care; only in seeing President Barack Obama fail.
What makes the recent tone of the national health care debate so ridiculous is that Americans have had "socialized medicine" for decades, and it has worked pretty well.
The popular Medicare program that Reagan warned against — and later tried to deny he ever opposed — covers 43 million people who are disabled or age 65 and older.
Then there's government health care for veterans and insurance for public employees. Members of Congress have especially good government health care plans.
* My biggest fear about health care reform is that we won't get any.
* My biggest concern about Obama's approach is that it isn't ambitious enough, especially now that he seems willing to give up on a government insurance option.
There are many improvements that can be made in our current system with electronic medical records and various cost-containment strategies. But I think the long-term solution is some form of single-payer health insurance involving privately delivered medical care — like Medicare.
Why wouldn't it work to open Medicare, or something like it, to more people? That could provide a safety net. Then, individuals or groups could buy supplemental private insurance if they wanted more coverage and could afford it, as Medicare recipients often do.
Every major industrialized nation except ours has some form of universal health care.
Are the "socialized medicine" systems in Canada, Australia, Britain and other European nations perfect? Of course not.
* But here's what you see in the United States that you don't see in those countries: millions of people with no health care coverage.
(That includes nearly 600,000 Kentuckians, or 14 percent of the state's population, according to U.S. Census estimates).
* Here's what else you don't see in those countries:
Millions more people who are scared of losing health insurance coverage if they get sick or lose their job.
People who can't get coverage because of "pre-existing" conditions.
And people who see their life savings depleted because they get sick.
You also don't see businesses struggling to pay spiraling health care costs for employees and retirees while trying to compete in an increasingly global economy with foreign businesses that don't bear such burdens.
- Talk show entertainers and Republican partisans have done an effective job of whipping up the frightened, ill-informed citizens we see at public meetings and protests across the country.
* But if they want to rant about "socialized medicine," they should put their money where their mouths are.
Members of Congress who oppose a government health insurance option for citizens should give up their own government coverage. Let them try to buy a similar plan in the private market.
Then they, the media hacks and other self-described "freedom-loving conservatives" should march down to their local Medicare office and renounce their "socialized medicine" benefits, now and in the future.
Yes, I know. Fat chance.
Great article, no?
XOXO
Me
thanks!!!! and yes, fat chance.
ReplyDeleteThanks Annie.
ReplyDeleteAs one of those 14% of Kentucky's population I do believe this article speaks truth and yes fat chance. They will never give up what they refuse to give to the rest of us.
ReplyDeleteThats what I'm talkin about!!!
ReplyDeleteThe same 'Reagan speech' is on Youtube, also.
ReplyDeleteMy second-home of Hawai'i has a public healthcare system that works very well. No one complains about waits for service; 'death panels', or other bulls*it.
It's time. The whole nation needs this.
There's not a chance in a blazing blue hell that Congress would give up their own insurance...
ReplyDeleteWonder why our government officials (especially the ones who are so strongly against this bill) don't get together with the government officials of the countries that have universal health coverage already and see how it's run and how it works (or HAVE they and I'm just oblivious to it??)
People are afraid of change. This is the reason why there is such an uproar over this.
We (Randall and I) will be losing our state insurance within the next month because Randall went back to work. He had to choose between staying on state help with insurance OR watch his family slowly go down on the sinking ship of barely being able to make ends meet.
So yes, I worry. And just for Randall's benefit, we (my family) need this bill to go through and do what it's claiming it will do. Without insurance of any kind we will never be able to afford Randall's cardiologist's bill. There is NO WAY we can pay out-of-pocket.
No doctor = no care.
No care = Randall stands a chance of getting sick again.
That just can not happen...
I just need desperately to see a doctor who won't take every penny of what money I have left to live on.
ReplyDeleteAnne, you know I have mentioned working for a doctor before. He sat around ranting and raving over our nation heading towards socialized medicine. He was so worried that some day he would be making less money as a doctor so he was squeezing all he could out of his patients insurance while he still could. I could never get over the outrageous fees he charged. I told him then if we did end up in socialized medicine, he would be partly to blame because of those high fees he charged. And this was back in the mid 80's.
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
ReplyDeleteThere are over 1500+ lobbyists in DC (as of a few months ago), all throwing $'s at the guys who do not support this bill, (and even MORE $'s at those who do).
XOXO
me
All because they are afraid of a little change... For something that COULD be very beneficial to the people who have no healthcare coverage what-so-ever!
ReplyDeleteFrom a blog I have yet to post...
ReplyDelete"However, lobbying spending is far greater. With national attention on health care reform, corporate interests spent $126 million in 2009 Q 1, and topped it with "the most cash on federal-level lobbying efforts in" Q 2. "The health sector was the No. 1 sector, spending $133 million during the second quarter of 2009. And within the 100-plus industries that CRP tracks, the pharmaceutical/health products industry was again the top dog on K Street, spending roughly $68 million during the quarter."
And THAT is just pocket change for these guys...
XOXO
Me
"Patients before Profits! Health Insurance reform was never an Option… it is a Necessity."
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteYou are most welcome Sweetie!
XOXO
me
ReplyDeleteWelcome Sweet Cille.
XOXO
me
ReplyDeleteSweet Becca;
I really do not care about their benefits.
Where I have my problem is that they are not working FOR us, only the $ they receive from special interest and lobbyists.
(There are over 1540+ such groups lobbying and paying them already (from insurance companies to big pharma too- and to the makers of medical equipment, even to sad Joe Blow who thinks he has insurance for a lifetime somehow).
One day soon if this does not get passed, it WILL come back to haunt all the moneygrubbers in DC.
That is called karma, Baby, and it always comes around.
XOXO
me
ReplyDeleteSweet Pamela!
You GO, Girl!
XOXO
Me
ReplyDeleteDear Will;
Truer words were never spoken-
Thank you!
XOXO
Me
Here is a comment I left elsewhere...
ReplyDeleteThis, from the horses mouth... http://energycommerce.house.gov/
Energy & Commerce Requests Information from Health Insurance Companies
Publications
Wednesday, 19 August 2009 09:24
As part of the Committee's ongoing investigation of the health insurance industry's business practices, Chairman Henry A. Waxman and Subcommittee Chairman Bart Stupak sent letters on Monday to the largest insurance companies requesting information on how the companies use the premiums collected from policyholders, businesses, and the government.
Aetna
AflacIncorporated
AllinaHealthGroup
AmericanInternationalGroup,Inc.
AmerigroupGroup
AssurantIncorporatedGroup
BlueCrossandBlueShieldofFlorida
BlueCrossBlueShieldofMassachusetts
BlueCrossBlueShieldofMichigan
BlueShieldofCalifornia
BlueCrossBlueShieldofAlabamaGroup
BlueCrossBlueShieldofLouisiana
BlueCrossBlueShieldofMinnesotaGroup
BlueCrossBlueShieldofNorthCarolinaGroup
BlueCrossBlueShieldofSouthCarolina
BlueCrossBlueShieldofTennesseeGroup
CareFirst
CenteneCorporationGroup
CIGNACorp.
CoventryHealthCare,Inc
DentegraGroup
GenworthFinancialGroup
GHIServicesGroup
GroupHealthCooperative
GuardianLifeGroup
HartfordFire&CasualtyGroup
HarvardPilgrimHealthCareGroup
HealthCareServiceCorporation
HealthInsurancePlanofNewYork(HIP)
HealthNetofCalifornia,Inc
HealthNet,Inc.
HealthNowNewYorkInc.
HighmarkInc
HorizonBlueCrossBlueShieldofNewJersey
HumanaInc.
IndependenceBlueCross
KaiserFoundationHealthPlan
LifetimeHealthcareGroup
MedicalMutualofOhioGroup
MetLife,Inc
MolinaHealthcareGroup
PremeraBlueCrossGroup
PrincipalFinancialGroup
TheRegenceGroup
TuftsAssociatedHMOInc.
UnitedHealthGroup
UniversalAmericanFinancialCorpGroup
UnumprovidentGroup
UPMCHealthSystemGroup
WellCareHealthPlans,Inc.
WellmarkBlueCrossBlueShield
WellPoint,Inc.
(As for myself, I can't wait to read those responses)!
It will be interesing to know this, won't it?
As for Randalls plight and your own too. (I have NOT forgotten that YOU are supposed to be under a doctors care also), I will be addressing that in another blog.
XOXO
Me
Sweet PeachieBaby!
ReplyDeleteI know well that sinking feeling, and pray that your help comes through and soon.
If your experience wa$ overhwleming to your sense of decency in the 1980's just imagine all the charges now!!!
I wish there was some sort of alliance of doctor office workers that would come out and speak up too.
If YOU have spoken, there has to be about 10 MILLION more that haven't spoken up.
(Most of those probably in fear that they will lose their employment AND the benefits that come with those jobs).
More and more saddening each and every day to too many of us.
XOXO
Me
GREAT BLOG ANNA!!!
ReplyDeleteMay I post the link to this blog on my blog?